Hold the Phone! Did Trump Just Break Some Rules… Even *After* Leaving Office?! (Spoiler: A Judge Says 'Yup')

Michael Isih
7/19/2025
5 min read
Article
Thinking man with question mark

Hold the Phone! Did Trump Just Break Some Rules… Even After Leaving Office?! (Spoiler: A Judge Says 'Yup')

Okay, grab your favorite beverage (mine's currently a lukewarm coffee – don't judge, deadlines are REAL) and let's talk about something kinda wild. Remember Rebecca Slaughter? She's a Democratic FTC Commissioner. Well, a judge just dropped a ruling hotter than a freshly microwaved Hot Pocket, saying that Trump unlawfully tried to remove her back in 2018. Yes, you read that right. 2018. We're still unpacking this drama.

So, basically, the judge is saying Ms. Slaughter is still a “rightful member” of the FTC. Imagine getting told four years later, “Hey, remember that job you thought you almost lost? Yeah, you still have it. Surprise!” It’s like finding a twenty in your old winter coat, but, you know, significantly more impactful.

Wait, Back Up. What Even Is the FTC?

Good question! Imagine a playground. The FTC, or Federal Trade Commission, is basically the playground monitor for businesses. They’re there to make sure everyone’s playing fair, nobody's bullying consumers with deceptive practices, and no one is monopolizing all the swings. They're all about protecting consumers and promoting competition in the marketplace. Important stuff, right?

They investigate things like misleading advertising, data security breaches, and illegal monopolies. They also set rules and guidelines for businesses to follow, and they can bring lawsuits against companies that violate the law. Think of them as the guardians of fair deals and reasonable internet browsing experiences.

So, What Actually Happened with Trump and Slaughter?

Here's where it gets interesting. In 2018, Trump, seemingly unhappy with the FTC’s composition (and let's be honest, he probably wasn't thrilled about a Democratic Commissioner), attempted to... well, let's just say 'restructure' things. Specifically, he tried to appoint a Republican Commissioner in a way that would have effectively forced Slaughter out. The details get a bit legal-y, but the gist is that the move allegedly violated the FTC Act. The FTC Act has a section that explicitly says that only three commissioners can be from one political party.

And because Washington is basically one giant chess board, Slaughter sued. And now, years later, the court has sided with her.

It's like a plot twist in a political thriller, except it's real life, and instead of explosions, we have meticulously worded legal documents. Though, sometimes, those legal documents feel just as explosive.

Why Does This Matter? I Just Want to Binge-Watch Netflix in Peace!

I get it. Politics can be a drag. But this ruling actually matters for a few reasons:

  • Checks and Balances, Baby! This case is a big win for the concept of checks and balances in government. It shows that even the President isn’t above the law and can’t just arbitrarily remove someone from their position because he doesn't like their party affiliation. Separation of Powers, in action, folks!

  • FTC Independence: The FTC is supposed to be an independent agency, free from political interference. This ruling reinforces that idea, ensuring the agency can do its job without fear of being manipulated by the White House. And when the FTC is doing its job it means lower gas prices when mergers threaten prices, and reasonable health care. That’s right, the FTC does stuff that actually helps your bottom line.

  • Future Presidents, Take Note: This sets a precedent. It sends a message to future presidents that they can't just get rid of people they disagree with without following the proper legal procedures. Consider it a 'do not disturb' sign for the Oval Office when it comes to the FTC.

  • Consumer Protection: A fully functioning, politically balanced FTC is better equipped to protect consumers from fraud and unfair business practices. Think about those annoying robocalls you get offering extended car warranties (even though you don't even own a car!). The FTC is one of the agencies working to stop those. Well, trying to, at least. Maybe this ruling will give them a little extra muscle.

Okay, Judge Judy, What Happens Next?

That's the million-dollar question, isn't it? The Justice Department, representing the government (and, technically, Trump, even though he's not technically the government anymore – see, confusing!) could appeal the ruling. Or, they could decide to just let it stand. It's all very dramatic.

If the ruling stands, Slaughter remains a Commissioner until her term expires. Which means the FTC can continue doing its thing, hopefully with a little less political interference. But this is Washington, so I wouldn’t bet my last dollar on things staying quiet.

My Take: This is Weird. But Also... Kinda Good?

Look, let's be honest, American politics are currently serving up some seriously strange storylines. Like, who knew we'd be dissecting legal battles from 2018 in…[checks calendar]… 2024? It's like a political version of Groundhog Day, but instead of Bill Murray reliving the same day, we're reliving the same administration, one legal battle at a time.

But in all seriousness, I think this ruling is a good thing. Not because I have any strong feelings about Rebecca Slaughter personally (I've never met her, although if she ever needs a lukewarm coffee buddy, I'm available!). But because it reinforces the idea that the rule of law matters. That presidents, past or present, can't just do whatever they want, whenever they want.

And hey, maybe this will encourage people to pay a little more attention to these seemingly obscure agencies like the FTC. Because, believe it or not, they actually have a big impact on our daily lives. From the products we buy to the internet we browse, the FTC is working (or trying to work) to make sure things are fair and honest. That's something we can all get behind, right?

So, what do you think? Is this a victory for democracy? A sign of the apocalypse? Or just another Tuesday in the wacky world of American politics? Sound off in the comments below. And please, for the love of all that is holy, tell me I'm not the only one who thinks this whole thing is a bit surreal.

(P.S. If anyone knows Rebecca Slaughter, tell her I said 'Hi' and that I admire her tenacity. And maybe ask her if she has any insider tips on avoiding robocalls. You know, for a friend.)

(P.P.S. I'm now officially accepting nominations for the most unintentionally hilarious headline of the year. This story is definitely a contender.)

Enjoyed this article? Share it with others!